Faith and “Internalized Homonegativity”: Contribute to Reality Based Theology.

For the first day of Lent, part of the readings referred to “taking up our cross”. One part of conventional Catholic teaching on homosexual persons, is that our orientation is the cross that we must take up, and deal with. I disagree - orientation in itself is a gift from God, not an ordeal to survive. The cross that we carry, as I wrote in a Lenten post last year, is the disordered teaching of the Church, the persecution that it brings in discrimination bullying, gay -bashing and hate-crime murders - and the internalized homophobia that drives a disproportionate number of us to suicide, or to less extreme pathological behaviour, in addictions or in the closet.
What is commonly referred to as “homophobia”, researcher William Skelton refers to more cautiously with the less emotive term, ” negativity”. In an email that he sent me yesterday, he described an academic research project he is undertaking, into the links between faith maturity and internalized homonegativity. Skelton, who is looking for participants for a master’s research project, makes an observation in his email that corroborates my own perception that mainstream theology on the subject is completely devoid of any basis in empirical research on our lived experience - because reliable research simply does not exist.
As I began to look for a project I began to realize there was very little scientifically rigorous literature detailing the experiences of gay men and lesbian women. For example, much of the work has had small unrepresentative populations or tests that did not measure what they were supposed to measure. At worst the surveys/ research were conducted by anti-gay or non- affirming GLBT groups. In an attempt to represent the broadest range of experience I am contacting the administrations of many different Christian organizations in an attempt to reach out to different groups whose voices have not necessarily been represented in the research.
CDF documents claim, with no evidence whatsoever, that homosexuality/homosexual acts lead us away from God. That is certainly not my experience, which shows the exact reverse. The anecdotal evidence I have encountered, and the ethnographic evidence showing that in many cultures, sexual minorities are associated with particular spiritual gifts, also suggest that the claim is false. But it seems there is no empirical evidence rooted in LGBT experience, either to contradict, or to confirm, the claim. On the other hand, there is a great deal of evidence on how perceptions of religious hostility contribute to LGBT depression, and even suicide. If we are to move towards reality-based theology, we need more empirical evidence .
The second focus of Skelton’s proposed research is on the important concept of ”faith maturity”, and its interaction with internalized negativity.
Furthermore, our faith/religion/ spirituality can be a mix of several double edged swords both helping and at times harming us; this is where my interest in faith maturity comes in. In some cases we can start to believe different parts of the negative messages society has about our sexuality which is also known as internalized homonegativity.
This project strikes me as eminently worthwhile. I will certainly be volunteering to participate myself, and would encourage my readers to do so too. For those who may be interested, I share the rest of Skelton’s email, verbatim:

“Dear Research Participant:Your participation in a research project is requested. The title of the study is “The relationship Between Faith Maturity Development and Internalized Homonegativity”. The research is being conducted by William Skelton, a graduate student in the Psychology Department at Barry University, and it is seeking information that will be useful in the fields of Psychology of Human Sexuality and Psychology of Religion. The aims of the research are to examine internalized homonegativity and faith maturity. In accordance with these aims, the following procedure will be used: questionnaires called Reactions to Homosexuality Scale, the Lesbian Internalized Homonegativity Scale, the Faith Maturity Scale, and a Demographics Scale follows this letter. I anticipate the number of participants to be 600. If you decide to participate in this research, you will be asked to do the following: Answer the questions on the following scales as appropriate: Reactions to Homosexuality Scale, the Lesbian Internalized Homonegativity Scale, the Faith Maturity Scale, and a Demographics Scale. The questionnaire is estimated to take no more than 40 minutes to complete.

Your consent to be a research participant is strictly voluntary and should you decline to participate or should you choose to drop out at any time during the study, there will be no adverse effects. If you are a student there will be no effect on your grades.

There are no risks of involved in this study. The following procedures will be used to minimize these risks: You can skip any questions you do not want to answer. There are no direct benefits to you for participating in this study; however, your participation will contribute to research in the areas of Psychology of Human Sexuality and Psychology of Religion. If you are a student you may be able to receive extra credit for your participation. Print a copy of this cover letter as proof of your participation.

All data is stored in a password-protected database at a web hosting site that provides top of the line virtual and physical security. By completing and submitting this electronic survey you are acknowledging that you are at least 18-years-old and that you voluntarily agree to participate in the study.

If you have any questions or concerns regarding the study or your participation in the study, you may contact me, William Skelton through Andrea Bello in the department of psychology, at (305) 899-3270, or by email[email protected], or my supervisor Dr. Muscarella, at (305) 899- 3275 or by email[email protected]. You may also contact the Institutional Review Board point of contact, Barbara Cook, at (305) 899- 3020.

Thank you for your participation.

Sincerely, William Skelton”

(Barry University is a private, Catholic university in the Dominican tradition, in Miami, Florida).

If you are willing to participate, Link to the Survey here,

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

3 comments for “Faith and “Internalized Homonegativity”: Contribute to Reality Based Theology.

  1. Jennifer Hynes
    February 29, 2012 at 10:49 am

    I have just done the survey, very interesting questions will look forward to the study results when they come out.

    • February 29, 2012 at 11:19 am

      Thanks for participating. I’ve not done so myself as yet - too busy lining up some interesting posts for today. I’ll do mine right after lunch.

  2. William Skelton
    March 31, 2012 at 8:01 pm

    Thank you both for your support. I am still collecting data, but time is of the essence!

Leave a Reply